top of page

The Effective Use of Prong Collars in Dog Training

Title: The Effective Use of Prong Collars in Dog Training

**This Post may contain affiliated Links which means I may receive commissions at no cost to you if you make a purchase or choose to sign up for a Program through that link.

Prong collars have been a subject of intense debate in the world of dog training. Over my 50 years of experience in breeding and training dogs, I've witnessed many trainers and handlers grapple with the question: Are they cruel torture devices or invaluable training tools? Are they safe for dogs when used correctly? Let's dive into the world of prong collars, understanding their purpose, how they work, and when and how to use them safely and effectively.

Connection Handler and Dog
Dog Focus, Attention with good correct training

**Understanding the Purpose and Function of Prong Collars**

Prong collars, also known as pinch collars, are designed to provide a physical correction during dog training by simulating the correction that one dog might give to another. These collars operate by applying pressure when the leash is pulled in a correction.

The question arises: Is physical correction necessary in dog training? The answer largely depends on the individual dog. While some dogs may respond well to purely positive reinforcement training methods, others may require a firmer approach to learn control and manners. It's worth noting that many successful trainers use a combination of positive reinforcement and mild physical corrections.

" Making a comaparison...In the realm of education for children, the question often surfaces: Is strict discipline and consequences necessary for effective learning? The answer is heavily influenced by the unique needs and personalities of individual students. Just as some children thrive in an environment of positive reinforcement and praise, others may require a more structured and disciplined approach to instill self-control and proper behavior. It's important to recognize that many accomplished educators strike a balance, using a combination of positive reinforcement and gentle disciplinary measures to help students develop into responsible and well-rounded individuals.

dog showing atention to owner
Connection between handler and dog

Pet owners typically have the dogs they have, without the luxury of cherry-picking exceptionally pliable dogs for training. Moreover, not all trainers possess the expertise to train dogs without any form of physical correction. For most owners and dogs, some level of physical correction becomes a necessary part of the training process.

**The Reality: Are Prong Collars Dangerous?**

Yes, prong collars, like all collars, carry inherent risks, including the risk of strangulation if left unattended. However, when used properly, prong collars are considered one of the safest options for delivering corrections. Other collar types, such as flat collars or fur savers, may require excessive force for an effective correction or pose risks to a dog's esophagus when used for firm corrections. In contrast, prong collars require less force to be effective, making them safer for dogs that pull or need a more substantial correction.

Certainly, let's delve into a more detailed and medically oriented explanation of why flat collars and fur savers can pose risks to a dog's esophagus when used for corrective purposes.

Flat Collars:

Flat collars are typically designed as simple bands around a dog's neck. When a correction is applied through a flat collar, it involves pulling on the leash, and this force is concentrated on a relatively small area of the neck. The anatomy of a dog's neck is such that it contains various sensitive structures, including the trachea (windpipe) and the esophagus (the tube that carries food and water from the mouth to the stomach).

Dog in stting position
dog in Sitz position

Excessive force applied through a flat collar can lead to significant pressure on the trachea and the esophagus, potentially causing injury. The trachea is a delicate structure composed of cartilage rings, and excessive pressure can damage or collapse these rings, leading to breathing difficulties and other health issues. Similarly, the esophagus, which lies close to the trachea, can also be compressed or irritated, potentially leading to discomfort, difficulty swallowing, and damage to the delicate lining.

Fur Savers:

Fur savers, which are a type of chain collar, are designed to reduce the risk of damaging a dog's fur while still providing correction. These collars consist of interlocking chain links. When a correction is administered through a fur saver, the chain links can cinch together, applying pressure around the dog's neck.

In the context of the esophagus, fur savers can pose risks when applied with excessive force or inappropriately. The chain links, when tightened, can create a narrow, constricting ring around the neck. If this tightens too much, it can press against the dog's throat and potentially affect the esophagus. This pressure can lead to discomfort, swallowing difficulties, and irritation of the esophageal lining.

Dog is heeling position
Dog anfd handler in Heeling and connection

It's important to emphasize that both flat collars and fur savers can be safe when used for their intended purposes, such as holding identification tags or attaching a leash for general control. However, when these collars are used for forceful corrections, especially with excessive pressure, there is an increased risk of harming the delicate structures in a dog's neck, including the esophagus and trachea.

This is one of the reasons why prong collars are considered safer when used for corrective purposes. They distribute pressure more evenly across the neck, reducing the risk of causing harm to sensitive structures and ensuring that corrections can be effective without excessive force. Proper use of a prong collar, with the right fit and applied as described in the previous explanation, minimizes the risks associated with collar use during training.

**How to Use a Prong Collar Safely**

To ensure the safe and effective use of a prong collar, follow these guidelines:

**1. Proper Fitment:** Prong collars should fit snugly and high on the dog's neck, just behind the ears. Avoid allowing the collar to be loose or positioned around the base or middle of the neck. Achieve the desired snugness by adding or removing links as necessary.

**2. Correcting Behavior:** When delivering a correction, remove slack from the leash quickly, rather than pulling forcefully. The motion should be a swift tug and release. You can accompany this with a negative marker word like "no" or immediately issue a command for an alternative behavior.

Dog wanting to catch ball
Dog in training control

**3. Tailoring Corrections:** Corrections must be tailored to the individual dog's sensitivity and response. Some dogs are "handler soft" and may require milder corrections, while others may need firmer ones to stop unwanted behavior or regain engagement.

**4. Balanced Training:** Maintain a balanced approach to training, rewarding positive behaviors as well as correcting negative ones. This balanced approach ensures that your dog enjoys training and understands what is expected.

**5. **Targeted Correction Scenarios:** Corrections are administered to dogs for specific reasons, primarily to communicate that their current behavior is unacceptable. When the undesired behavior ceases, the corrective pressure is released, which is a positive outcome for the dog. Following the cessation of the unwanted behavior, the final positive reinforcement is introduced, reinforcing the idea that they've made the right choice.

For example, when a dog lunges at cyclists, a correction is promptly applied to discourage this behavior. The cessation of the lunging triggers the release of pressure, offering a favorable experience for the dog. Subsequently, a reward is provided, reinforcing the notion that refraining from lunging at cyclists is the desirable behavior.

Dog ready to grab pillow for protection work
Dog in Protection Training

**Choosing the Right Prong Collar**

**Selecting the Right Prong Collar:** When choosing a prong collar for your dog's training needs, it's essential to prioritize quality and durability. Among the various options available in the market, Herm Sprenger stands out as the most trusted and respected brand in the industry.

**Herm Sprenger Prong Collars:** Herm Sprenger prong collars are renowned for their exceptional craftsmanship and design. These collars are meticulously engineered to meet the highest standards of quality and safety. The choice of materials, precision manufacturing, and attention to detail make Herm Sprenger prong collars a top choice for professional trainers and dog owners alike.

Prong collar
Image of a Prong Collar

**Durability and Longevity:** One of the standout features of Herm Sprenger prong collars is their remarkable durability. Crafted to withstand the rigors of training, these collars are built to last a lifetime. This longevity ensures that your investment in your dog's training equipment is well-spent, as you won't need to replace the collar frequently. The robust construction of Herm Sprenger collars ensures that they can withstand the wear and tear of consistent use while maintaining their effectiveness and safety.

In summary, opting for a high-quality prong collar from a trusted brand like Herm Sprenger ensures that you are making a wise investment in your dog's training journey. The durability and reliability of these collars make them a valuable tool for effective and safe training, providing long-term benefits for both you and your canine companion.

**A Final Note on Prong Collars**

Remember that prong collars are not meant to be worn continuously. They should be used strictly for training purposes and removed afterward. Like all collars, prong collars pose a strangulation risk if left on an unsupervised dog.

In conclusion, prong collars can be valuable tools when used correctly and responsibly in dog training. They are not cruel devices when applied with care and tailored to the dog's needs. Always prioritize your dog's safety, and consult with a professional trainer if you have any doubts or concerns about using a prong collar in your training regimen.

We recommend to watch the following Video:

Recent Posts

See All