top of page

Unleashing the Controversy: Dog Training Methodologies and the Canine Conundrum

Title: Unleashing the Controversy: Dog Training Methodologies and the Canine Conundrum


"Throughout the years, I have witnessed a significant evolution in dog training methodologies. My own training, which dates back to the 1970s, reflects an era where aversive and harsh techniques were commonly employed. I can personally attest to the effectiveness of these methods, as they often aligned with the prevailing belief in the influence of pack survival behavior. Dogs were subjected to punishment, growling, biting, and dominance by their perceived alpha, reflecting a starkly different approach compared to contemporary methods.

In the context of the 1970s, the 'Pressure, Release, Reward Method' was the predominant dog training paradigm. This technique was not limited to dogs; it was also applied to horse training. My introduction to it came from a Mexican-Indian mentor who imparted the wisdom of the Antonio Aguilar Horses and their 'Round Pen Training.' This method, rooted in ancient traditions of indigenous peoples and early horsemanship, emphasized pressure and release as a means of communication with horses. I fondly recall incorporating these principles into my training approach.

My journey into the professional dog training realm began in the 1970s when I acquired a guard dog and established a business specializing in patrol services and personal protection. Remarkably, this endeavor found success as I secured over 50 contracts throughout Puerto Rico. Notably, I was not only the sole woman but also the youngest in the field, managing such a business. Our clients comprised top CEOs and prestigious companies, and the high level of training my dogs received led to their involvement in advertisements and television soap operas of the time.

I share this background not to boast but to offer insight into my early experiences in dog training. It illustrates the significant transformations the field has undergone over the years. The adjustments have required a willingness to explore and analyze new systems, a process that was entirely novel to me. However, I firmly believe in the power of learning and adaptability to propel progress and success, both in terms of personal growth and as a responsible dog owner.

I am enthusiastic about sharing my observations and insights regarding the evolution of dog training throughout the years. This journey has been marked by remarkable changes and innovations, reinforcing my conviction that openness to new methodologies is fundamental to our growth and the well-being of our canine companions."

We all know that Dog Training Methodologies has long been a subject of debate and controversy among pet owners, enthusiasts, and professionals. The source of this discord stems from the diversity of training methodologies and the passionate beliefs of individuals who subscribe to these different methods. In reality, dogs are unique beings, each with their own set of experiences, genes, upbringing, temperaments, and characters. This blog will delve into the various training methodologies, from traditional to modern, and examine the controversies they spark. It will emphasize the importance of understanding that a one-size-fits-all approach doesn't work, and training must be tailored to the individual dog. We'll explore the concept of balanced training, the fine line between correction and cruelty, the role of science in training, and the historical context of dog training.

I. The Diversity of Dog Owners:

People who own and train dogs can be categorized into various groups, each with its own distinct approach to training:

1. **The Traditionalists:** These individuals rely on age-old methods passed down through generations. They believe in using dominance, leash corrections, and punitive measures to establish authority over their dogs.

2. **The Positive Reinforcement Enthusiasts:** Advocates of positive reinforcement training focus on rewarding desired behaviors and ignoring or redirecting unwanted ones. This methodology is built on the idea of creating a strong bond between dog and owner through trust and cooperation.

3. **The Science-Based Trainers:** This group looks to scientific research on canine behavior and psychology to inform their training methods. They believe in evidence-based practices and the use of operant conditioning to modify behavior.

4. **The Hybrid Approach:** Many trainers blend different methods, employing positive reinforcement for obedience and traditional correction methods in certain situations.

II. The Balancing Act:

Balanced training is a methodology that seeks to strike a middle ground between positive reinforcement and traditional correction-based training. It involves using rewards to encourage desired behaviors and corrections to discourage unwanted behaviors. The key is to apply corrections carefully, ensuring they are timely and appropriate, and not excessively punitive. The effectiveness of balanced training often depends on the skill and understanding of the trainer.

III. The Thin Line between Correction and Cruelty:

Determining what is aversive and what is abusive is a challenge. While some level of correction may be necessary to communicate with a dog, it's crucial to avoid causing psychological harm. Training should never cause fear, anxiety, or harm to the dog. The key is to maintain a balance, applying corrections judiciously and with compassion.

IV. The Role of Science:

Science provides invaluable insights into dog behavior and training techniques, but it's not the sole compass. Training should be a blend of science and art, considering the individuality of each dog and the relationship between the dog and the owner.

V. Historical Perspective:

Historically, dogs have been trained through methods that may not align with modern understanding. However, it's essential to remember that times, values, and knowledge have evolved. While past methods may have produced successful working dogs, the ethical treatment of animals has gained greater recognition in recent years.

VI. What Makes a Standout Trainer:

A standout trainer is someone who understands the needs and nuances of individual dogs, respects their well-being, and tailors training accordingly. Success in training can be measured not only by accomplishments in competitions but by the happiness and welfare of the dog and the owner's satisfaction.

VII. Training Methodologies:

1. **Traditional Training:** This approach emphasizes dominance and obedience, often using aversive techniques like leash corrections, prong collars, and punishments to control the dog's behavior.

2. **Positive Reinforcement:** This method relies on rewarding desired behaviors with treats, praise, or toys, and ignoring or redirecting unwanted behaviors. It focuses on creating a strong, positive relationship between dog and owner.

3. **Science-Based Training:** Based on principles of operant conditioning, this method uses positive reinforcement for desired behaviors and negative punishment (removing rewards) for unwanted behaviors. It is informed by scientific research on dog behavior.

4. **Balanced Training:** This approach combines elements of positive reinforcement and traditional correction methods, aiming for a middle ground that emphasizes rewards for good behavior and corrections for unwanted behavior when necessary.

VIII. Other Training Methodologies:

1. **Clicker Training:** Clicker training is a subset of positive reinforcement training. It uses a small device called a clicker to make a distinct sound when a dog exhibits a desired behavior. The click is followed by a reward (usually a treat), associating the sound with positive reinforcement. This method provides clear and immediate feedback to the dog and is highly effective for teaching new behaviors and tricks.

2. **Electronic Training (E-Collars):** Electronic training methods involve the use of electronic collars, also known as e-collars or shock collars. These collars can emit a range of stimuli, from a mild vibration to a low-level electrical stimulation, to communicate with the dog. However, the use of electronic collars is highly controversial, as misuse can result in physical and psychological harm to the dog. Many animal welfare organizations advocate against their use, emphasizing alternative, more humane methods.

3. **Alpha Training:** Alpha training is rooted in the belief that dogs are pack animals and must view their human owners as the alpha or leader of the pack. It involves establishing dominance through methods such as maintaining a strict hierarchy, controlling resources, and using body language and assertive commands. This approach has faced criticism for its potential to create fear and anxiety in dogs.

4. **Model/Rival Training:** Model/Rival training is a technique that uses a trained dog as a model to demonstrate desired behaviors to an untrained dog. The untrained dog observes the model dog's actions and responses to commands, facilitating the learning process. It is an effective way to teach complex behaviors through observational learning.

5. **Behavior Modification:** Behavior modification is a versatile approach that involves altering a dog's behavior through positive reinforcement, negative punishment, or a combination of both. It is often used to address specific behavioral issues, such as aggression, fear, or anxiety. Behavior modification relies on understanding the root causes of the behavior and applying appropriate techniques to change it.

6. **Negative Punishment:** Negative punishment is a type of operant conditioning that involves removing a desirable stimulus to decrease unwanted behavior. For example, if a dog jumps on people, a negative punishment approach would involve turning away or withdrawing attention when the dog jumps. This helps the dog learn that jumping leads to the removal of attention.

It's important to recognize that the effectiveness of these training methodologies can vary depending on the dog's personality, the trainer's skill, and the specific context. It's advisable to make your own research, read about the different training methodologies, use your own common sense and learn to read your dog and analize, Yes you may also consult with a professional dog trainer or behaviorist that has proven to have achieved great results to determine the most appropriate approach for your individual dog's needs and to ensure their well-being throughout the training process. The key to successful training is understanding and communication, fostering a positive relationship between dog and owner, and ensuring the dog's happiness and welfare are paramount.


In the world of dog training, controversy will likely always exist due to the diversity of beliefs and methods. The key is to recognize that dogs are unique individuals and that effective training should be tailored to their needs. Understanding the balance between correction and cruelty, respecting scientific knowledge, and appreciating historical context can help guide dog owners to choose the right approach for their four-legged companions. Ultimately, a standout trainer is one who prioritizes the well-being and happiness of the dog above all else.

**This Post may contain affiliated Links which means I may receive commissions at no cost to you if you make a purchase or choose to sign up for a Program through that link.